OP ED - ALTERNATIVE PUBLIC SAFETY RESOURCES
AVAILABLE IN SAN FRANCISCO
By Ann Grogan
March 15, 2010
While our Police Chief wrestles with cutting $47 million
from next year's budget with certain layoffs coming, San Franciscans
don't have to wait. We have an option for increasing police
protection in our neighborhoods. It's the city-chartered,
Police-Commission-regulated, and privately-funded Patrol Special
Police.
We should inundate city leaders with pressure to get the
word out now, because this unique police force is ready, willing,
and able to protect us as they do in many neighborhoods across
the city, including my own Glen Park. www.glenparksafety.com.
Patrol Special Police don't hesitate to take on thugs and
protect both their private clients and anyone else in danger.
That's what Patrol Special Robert Burns did on February 7
when he was patrolling outside his private client's nightclub
in Fisherman's Wharf. He saw two men shooting, drew his side
arm, fired, and quickly brought one man down but sadly, not
until after a person had been murdered and four others seriously
injured. Many other lives were likely saved by his quick and
professional action.
Patrol Specials are better known for early-intervention,
crime-prevention oriented patrols that resolve local incidents
early and with discretion, before they become expensive, costly
crimes.
Yet city leaders and the Police Chief are mysteriously silent
in recognizing their courage and contribution to public safety.
The SFPD's press release doesn't even mention Officer Burn's
name, however, it does list the name of the shooter. Their
website says that Patrol Specials "are NOT (sic.) employees
of the SFPD" but are "private patrol persons who
contract to perform security duties of a private nature,"
and "are not allowed to perform any type of general law
enforcement duties." It mentions that Patrol Specials
back up SFPD foot patrol officers, but only "as private
citizens."
To me, it's an advantage that my Patrol Special Officer is
not an employee of the SFPD. I don't want more highly-paid
civil service SFPD officers who already earn average salaries
that exceed those paid in other major cities like New York
City, Boston, and Chicago, not to mention added future costs
for a lifetime pension that must be paid by my great grandchildren
-- and beyond.
True, Patrol Specials don't have peace officer powers of
arrest. Consequently, some say they can't really help us because
they have the same powers of arrest that you and I do. That's
a legal distinction without a practical difference.
Arrest is seldom needed in neighborhood policing and citizens
aren't trained or comfortable in making an arrest in the first
place. As we now know, Patrol Specials won't hesitate to draw
a weapon and fire if my life is threatened, then make an arrest
even if the SFPD says they don't engage in law enforcement.
Patrol Specials not only provide effective police services
that save taxpayers money, but they serve limited geographic
areas and often arrive at the scene before the SFPD can respond,
just like Officer Burns did.
Even better, Patrol Specials stay put, get to know us and
patterns of neighborhood life, listen to crime reports on
their police radios, intervene early to prevent crime to begin
with, and advise us about self-protection and safety matters.
They become valued and welcome members of our neighborhood
family.
A survey of Patrol Special clients was conducted last fall
by San Jose State University Professor Edward P. Stringham.
Stringham found that Patrol Special Police are enthusiastically
viewed as a proactive rather than a reactive solution to the
problem of crime. Clients said that "Patrol Specials
simply make neighborhoods a safer place to live and work."
Now that's effective policing by any other name!
BIOGRAPHY
Ann Grogan is a California attorney (inactive status) and
former Deputy Attorney General. She practiced law for 14 years
until she got it right, then became a small business owner
with a home-based Internet fashion business. She occasionally
consults on organizational development. She's a client in
Glen Park of the Patrol Specials, and a former client in the
Castro.
Ann Grogan, J.D.
30 yr. resident in Glen Park
2912 Diamond St., Ste. 239
San Francisco, CA 94131
|